For a long time a low-intensity regional conflict within the Middle East has been ongoing, however it took Hamas’s shock assault on Israel on Oct. 7 to convey this battle into sharper focus.
For a while, a largely shadowy “grey zone” contest for affect in Syria and Iraq has taken place. Occasionally, “tit-for-tat assaults” play out elsewhere within the Middle East. But now, the battle is coalescing right into a full-blown Iranian axis of resistance that has been rising stronger for years.
When I left the National Security Council in 2018, I expressed critical considerations that the US was prone to overcorrecting its counterterrorism coverage consideration and assets by pivoting too arduous in the direction of great-power competitors. Policy critics from outdoors the Trump administration opined that 9/11 had disproportionately “warped US international coverage,” concluding that it could take years to right.
October 7 validates how strategically dangerous pivoting away from the Middle East and undoing regular counterterrorism investments might be.
To be honest, each the Trump and Biden administrations wished to focus extra on great-power competitors. As a consequence, in the previous few years, whereas the US was realigning its international coverage focus to counter Russia and China’s affect, Iran seized loads of political house to fill the vacuum and wage a conflict with its proxies.
Biden officers have been saying that it’s untimely to foretell whether or not a wider conflict would get away within the Middle East. Yet in current days, a suspected Israeli drone strike killed a high Hamas chief in Lebanon. Israel reportedly killed a second militant commander from Hezbollah a number of days later in southern Lebanon.
In Iran, the Islamic State was liable for a martyrdom assault, killing scores of individuals throughout a memorial. In solidarity with Hamas, Houthi militants in Yemen are disrupting the free stream of commerce within the Red Sea; these Houthi disruptions triggered retaliatory American-led missile strikes. All of that is occurring whereas Israeli and Hezbollah skirmishing continues to ratchet up tensions on the Israel-Lebanon border.
In Gaza, the Israel Defense Forces continues its punishing army marketing campaign in opposition to Hamas. As a results of Oct. 7, Israel has additionally elevated its safety measures within the West Bank by proscribing the liberty of motion of Palestinian residents.
If all of this isn’t convincing sufficient {that a} wider conflict is right here, add a US drone strike in Baghdad to the counterterrorism ledger.
So, sure, there’s certainly a regional conflict within the Middle East. But further context is so as. Before Oct. 7, a Middle East conflict was on a sluggish boil for years. None of this got here into focus for me till I used to be a part of an official delegation to Israel in 2017 whereas serving within the Trump administration.
Just a number of hours spent on the Golan Heights helps me contextualize the present Israel-Gaza conflict via a broader geo-strategic lens. From there, I concluded that Syria is a metaphor for competitors and battle that goes effectively past US-led counterterrorism campaigning in opposition to the Islamic State..
In Syria, Russia helps Assad’s malign regime, a state that waged a genocidal civil conflict in opposition to its personal folks, to not point out holding American journalist Austin Tice hostage for over a decade. Syria can also be the identical terrain the place the US and Kurds stay locked in a low-level combat in opposition to ISIS and different militants.
In the summer season of 2017, though the continuing ISIS marketing campaign and US hostages have been very a lot on my thoughts when our celebration was hosted by Israel, I noticed few parallels between the US-driven ISIS marketing campaign and the way Israelis considered the ever-present threats from Hamas and Hezbollah.
Hamas’s terrorist assaults have already opened a Pandora’s field for unifying an axis in opposition to Israel, which signifies that the Biden administration has to reboot a counterterrorism technique that takes under consideration these regional dynamics to confront an Iran-directed axis that is rather more expansive than what I noticed in 2017.
None of that is hype; since spring, Hezbollah, Hamas and Iranian leaders have come collectively to wage the “final jihad” in opposition to Israel. It appears that Iran has unified an array of jihadists and Shia fighters by providing what the welter of different factions couldn’t: a violent antipathy in the direction of Israel.
In hindsight, I did not have time to mirror on classes realized from a frenetic few days in 2017, till our itinerary concluded on the King David Hotel in Jerusalem; paradoxically, this was the scene of a horrific terrorist assault in a bygone period final century. But I knew sufficient about terrorism to understand that the burden of historical past on Israelis and Palestinians can’t be understood with out figuring out the lengthy arc of political violence within the area.
So, occasions in Gaza and the West Bank have come full circle; even the ghosts of the Israel-Palestine colonial previous are being resurrected in polarizing debates about this battle.
In this wider conflict, that is all to Iran’s benefit.
Christopher P. Costa is an adjunct affiliate professor with Georgetown University’s Security Studies Program, Walsh School of Foreign Service. He is a former profession intelligence officer and was particular assistant to the president and senior director for counterterrorism on the National Security Council from 2017 to 2018.
Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This materials might not be printed, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.