Frontiers | Comparison of pre

January 31, 2024

20

Introduction

Postpartum despair (PPD) is a extreme however treatable dysfunction that features excessive unhappiness, anxiousness, and adjustments in degree of power, sleep and urge for food, and it happens in some girls inside 4 weeks after giving delivery (1). Unfortunately, postpartum despair is on the rise in all societies. For instance, in a scientific evaluation on 565 research, Wang et al. (2) discovered that the prevalence of PPD is 17.22%. They discovered excessive heterogeneity as a result of developed or underdeveloped international locations below examine. Iran as a creating nation has been discovered to have excessive prevalence of PPD. According to a scientific evaluation together with 1,165 individuals by Veisani and Sayehmiri (3), the prevalence of PPD was 28.7% amongst Iranian girls, and this price was 39.6% in girls with a optimistic historical past of despair. A latest examine in Khuzestan, Iran confirmed that the prevalence of PPD is 38.8%, and components resembling historical past of PPD, having neonates with congenital malformation, and admission of neonates to intensive care unit have been efficient predictors of PPD (4).

PPD has maternal and neonatal penalties. Problems associated to bodily well being, psychological and communication issues, and harmful behaviors are examples of maternal penalties of PPD, whereas decreased neonatal anthropometric measures, sleep disturbances, and motor and cognitive retardation are the damaging penalties of PPD affecting neonates and infants (5). Albeit not quite common, suicidal ideation is likely one of the penalties of PPD in girls which is a supply of concern and fear (6).

The affiliation between PPD and COVID-19 pandemic has been studied in some international locations. In a examine carried out within the United States, for instance, Shuman et al. (7) discovered that one-third and one-fifth of the studied girls had PPD and extreme PPD, respectively. Also, in a scientific evaluation by Chen et al. (8) discovered that the prevalence of PPD throughout COVID-19 pandemic was 34%, which was a lot larger than the identical price earlier than emergence of the pandemic. Another systematic evaluation by Safi-Keykaleh et al. (9) which included 24 research discovered that in keeping with Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) and contemplating rating >13, the prevalence of PPD throughout COVID-19 pandemic was 28%. However, there may be proof suggesting no distinction between PPD earlier than and after the pandemic. For instance, Waschmann et al. (10) of their examine on 557 girls earlier than pandemic and 504 girls after pandemic discovered that the prevalence of PPD was comparable within the two teams.

Although quite a few research have been carried out on PPD earlier than emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic in Iran, there may be paucity of analysis concerning the prevalence of and components related to PPD throughout this pandemic in Iran. Therefore, this examine was designed to check the prevalence of PPD and the components affecting it earlier than and after the COVID-19 pandemic in Ahvaz, Iran.

Materials and strategies

Inclusion/exclusion standards

Women with fundamental literacy who had given delivery 1–6 months previous to the examine, have been aged 18–35 and resident within the city areas, and had willingness to take part on this examine have been recruited. Women with bodily or psychological issues throughout being pregnant, and people experiencing aggravating occasions through the 6 months previous to the examine or having a disabled little one have been excluded from the examine. The inclusion/exclusion standards for postpartum girls earlier than pandemic was much like these of the current examine (4).

Sampling

Six public well being facilities (three from the west financial institution and three from the east financial institution of the Karun River in Ahvaz, Iran) have been chosen randomly from amongst 60 facilities. The following system was used for sampling:

A complete variety of 600 was thought of for sampling. We enrolled 100 girls from every public well being middle. One of the researchers (MB) visited every of those public well being facilities each day and ready a listing of ladies who had given delivery to be later contacted. Eligible girls who offered written knowledgeable consent have been requested to fill-up two questionnaires, and the identical analysis workforce member (MB) was obtainable in case the individuals had any query.

Measures

A demographic questionnaire and Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) have been used to gather knowledge. The demographic questionnaire included questions on age, occupation, academic attainment, variety of kids, financial standing, and husband’s age and academic attainment. The content material validity of this questionnaire was accepted.

EPDS has 10 questions and assesses the emotions of respondents through the previous 7 days. The scores of every query ranges from zero to a few. The complete rating of this questionnaire is 30, and scores greater than 10 signify postnatal despair (11). The validity and reliability of this questionnaire have been accepted by Mazhari and Nakhaee (12) and Galini Moghadam et al. (13) in Iran. EPDS was additionally the identical instrument used for assessing PPD earlier than pandemic in 2019 (4).

Procedure

Eligible girls have been invited to every middle and requested to finish the demographic and EPDS questionnaires. If they’d problem in finishing the questionnaire, one of many researchers (MB) was obtainable to assist them. A bunch of 504 girls who have been assessed in 2019 for the prevalence of postpartum despair and the components affecting it have been thought of as a management group (4). To abide by moral concerns, after analyzing the info, these girls who have been screened with EPDS and scored larger than 10, have been beneficial to be visited by a psychiatrist.

Statistical evaluation

Data of this examine was analyzed utilizing SPSS model 22. The Shapiro–Wilk check was used to check the traditional distribution of information. Independent t-test and Chi-square exams have been used to check variations between the 2 teams concerning steady and categorical knowledge, respectively. Logistic regression was used to check variations between the 2 teams concerning despair with a 95% confidence interval. P < 0.05 was thought of statistically vital.

Results

In this examine, 850 girls in postpartum interval have been screened of whom 600 have been discovered to be eligible and have been in contrast with 504 of their counterparts earlier than the pandemic. Demographic traits of the individuals through the COVID-19 pandemic are illustrated in Table 1. The imply ± SD age of ladies was 28.46 ± 6.38 and 29.07 ± 6.3 in girls with out and with PPD, respectively. The two teams didn’t present any vital distinction concerning husband’s age, variety of kids, academic attainment of the individuals and their husbands, and the individuals’ and their husband’s occupation. Women with out PPD had considerably higher financial standing as compared with girls with PPD (p = 0.02).

www.frontiersin.org

Table 1. Demographic traits of individuals in keeping with the severity of despair throughout COVID-19 pandemic.

There was no vital distinction between the 2 teams concerning historical past of PPD. Women with PPD had considerably extra medical issues throughout their being pregnant (p < 0.0001).

Factors associated to COVID-19 an infection amongst girls with and with out PPD through the COVID-19 pandemic have been assessed. There was no vital distinction between the 2 teams concerning the impact of pandemic on the choice for conception, having COVID-19 an infection throughout present being pregnant, and hospitalization on account of an infection. Surprisingly, the speed of vaccination amongst girls with out PPD was considerably decrease compared to girls with PPD (p = 0.011) (knowledge usually are not proven in desk).

When we pooled knowledge for girls with and with out PPD earlier than and after COVID-19 pandemic, girls with PPD have been considerably older, have been much less employed, and had larger college schooling (p < 0.05; Table 2). Before the pandemic, 191 (31.8%) of the ladies had PPD, whereas this price rose to 409 (68.2%) through the pandemic (p = 0.0001).

www.frontiersin.org

Table 2. Comparison of ladies with and with out PPD earlier than and after COVID-19 pandemic.

For a greater understanding of the connection of despair with COVID-19 pandemic we used logistic regression, and the outcomes of this check are introduced in Table 3. As this desk reveals, postpartum girls throughout COVID-19 pandemic have been 8.727 occasions extra more likely to have PPD (95% CI: 5.919–12.868). Also, postpartum girls with highschool schooling and people having a highschool diploma have been 2.454 and a couple of.054 occasions extra more likely to have PPD in comparison with girls with a college diploma (95% CI: 1.508–3.996 and 1.302–3.241, respectively).

www.frontiersin.org

Table 3. Logistic regression of the connection between postpartum despair and COVID-19 pandemic.

Discussion

This examine was designed to judge the connection between the COVID-19 pandemic and PPD. Our outcomes confirmed that COVID-19 pandemic was a danger issue for PPD. During the pandemic, 68.2% of the ladies had PPD in comparison with 31.8% earlier than pandemic, which is according to earlier research. Shuman et al. (7), for instance, in a examine on 670 American girls in postpartum interval discovered that one out of three girls collaborating of their examine had PPD, and one in 5 girls had extreme despair, whereas earlier than the pandemic this price was 6.5–12.9%. Contrary to our outcomes, nonetheless, Erten et al. (14) in a examine in Turkey discovered that the prevalence of PPD was 17.4%, which is far smaller than what we present in our examine. This discrepancy could also be attributed to the truth that we collected knowledge when vaccination of pregnant girls had not turn out to be a routine apply in Iran. In reality, 32.4 and 21.2% of the ladies with out and with PPD in our examine had not acquired vaccination and round 40% of the ladies within the two teams had acquired just one dose of vaccine. Furthermore, throughout residence quarantine in Iran, pregnant girls may not have acquired ample care from well being suppliers, or they could have refused to attend the clinics (15). Also, prenatal and postnatal visits throughout this era have been so brief that analysis of psychological well being was not doable.

In a scientific evaluation together with 6,480 postpartum girls principally have been from developed international locations, Chen et al. (8) discovered that the prevalence of PPD was 34% through the pandemic, which was a lot larger than the speed reported earlier than the pandemic. This prevalence is far decrease than what we present in our examine (68.2% of ladies had PPD). This discrepancy might be defined by the truth that the prevalence of PPD amongst Iranian girls earlier than the COVID-19 pandemic was larger than that in developed international locations, as attested by Veisani and Sayehmiri’s (3) who reported a prevalence of 28.7% for PPD in a scientific evaluation.

Our outcomes confirmed that COVID-19 pandemic elevated the chance of PPD by 8.727. In a examine on 330 Greek girls in postpartum interval, Micha et al. (16) discovered that whereas the prevalence of PPD was 13.2%, most of the studied girls (24.8%) confirmed excessive ranges of antenatal anxiousness through the COVID-19 pandemic. According to Nakic Rados et al. (17), the speed of hysteria throughout being pregnant is excessive, which reduces instantly after childbirth after which barely will increase 6 weeks postpartum. They discovered excessive price of comorbidities (75%) between anxiousness and PPD. Unfortunately, within the present examine we didn’t measure the individuals’ degree of hysteria and stress for the reason that excessive degree of hysteria throughout COVID-19 pandemic and lack of ample vaccination might need been predisposing components for PPD.

Our outcomes confirmed that girls with highschool schooling and people having a highschool diploma have been 2.454 and a couple of.054 occasions extra more likely to have PPD in comparison with girls with college levels. Also, Liang et al. (18) reported that 30% of the studied girls had PPD, and components resembling: immigration, poor social help, and fear about getting COVID-19 an infection have been related to PPD. It is value mentioning that the components related to PPD are totally different from one society to a different.

Strengths and limitations of the examine

This was the primary examine to judge the postpartum despair of Iranian girls throughout COVID-19 pandemic. For a greater understanding of the impact of the pandemic, we in contrast our outcomes with a earlier examine that was carried out in 2019 earlier than the pandemic. Despite its strengths, nonetheless, this examine has some limitations. First we didn’t recruit girls randomly, and this may increasingly have an effect on the generalizability of the findings. Second, we didn’t test the anxiousness, worry, or stress of ladies together with their despair. According to different research, anxiousness and stress could set off PPD.

Conclusion

The outcomes of this examine confirmed that the prevalence of PPD was doubled through the COVID-19 pandemic. Therefore, policymakers are beneficial to contemplate some methods to help girls throughout being pregnant and postpartum interval particularly throughout crises resembling COVID-19 pandemic. Further research measuring anxiousness, stress, and PPD are wanted to attract a particular conclusion about PPD throughout crises resembling COVID-19 pandemic.

Data availability assertion

Ethics assertion

The research involving human individuals have been reviewed and accepted by Ahvaz Jundishapur University of Medical Sciences. The sufferers/individuals offered their written knowledgeable consent to take part on this examine.

Author contributions

Funding

Conflict of curiosity

Publisher’s observe

References

1. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. fifth ed. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association (2013).

Google Scholar

2. Wang Z, Liu J, Shuai H, Cai Z, Fu X, Liu Y, et al. Mapping international prevalence of despair amongst postpartum girls. Transl Psychiatry. (2021) 11:543. doi: 10.1038/s41398-021-01663-6